That’s a Good Question


Ian and I were sitting at the dinner table a few nights ago, when we had this conversation:

Renee: During the years of the Obama Presidency, I think lots of people in this country became more racist. Beyond unconscious bias, I mean. They consciously became more racist.

Ian: But folks have always been like that.

Renee: Oh, for sure.

It’s clear that the Obama Presidency brought people out of the woodwork who were emboldened when they had a President to “Other” in that way. And the Trump Presidency brought even more people out of the woodwork who are emboldened in their racism.

But I guess I mean this: During the years of the Obama Presidency, White Christian America began to feel as though they were tangibly losing influence, so —

Ian:Why not then become more Christian?

Ian anticipated what I was going to say, which was that White Christian America doubled down on protecting its whiteness. But if Christians were worried about losing influence, why not become more Christian? In word? In deed? In message? In collective action?

I should say that by “White Christian America” I mean something specific. This is the terminology of Robert P. Jones and the Public Religion Research Institute. In his book The End of White Christian America, Jones argues that changing demographics are impacting the nation in these areas:

1) racial ethnicity in the United States (population trends indicate that by approximately 2045, those deemed as ‘white’ will no longer be a majority of the U.S. population)


2) religious disaffiliation (approximately 22.8% of Americans are no longer formally affiliated with any particular religious organization)

These have paired to raise anxieties among white Christians and their leaders.

Jones argues that in the wake of losing cultural and political influence, White Christian America began to assert its whiteness further and work tangibly to protect it.

Ian’s question has some grief in it. Worried about losing influence. . . ?

Why not then become more Christian?

Renee Roederer


2 thoughts on “That’s a Good Question

  1. Such a thought-provoking question. Does it maybe have something to do with the fact that being Christian is something we do by choice, whereas being white is something we have absolutely no control over?


    1. It makes me wonder which identity marker people are making primary in their lives. In honesty, both are constructed identities. There is skin color itself (not chosen) and there is everything associated with the designation “white” (that which is constructed and given to some by virtue of skin color, also chosen) That designation has more to do with power than skin color.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s